Loading...
Duplication of referral, a tsunami of paper: how much does it cost the Irish health services?
Walsh, Nicola Malone, Lisa
Walsh, Nicola
Malone, Lisa
Advisors
Editors
Other Contributors
Departments
Date
2022-01-10
Date Submitted
Keywords
cost
Duplicate referrals
Waiting list
Duplicate referrals
Waiting list
Other Subjects
Subject Mesh
Planned Date
Start Date
Collaborators
Principal Investigators
Files
Alternative Titles
Publisher
Abstract
Background: Prolonged waiting lists increase costs as medical problems may become more expensive to fix. There are also hidden financial costs. Irish Clinical Genetic services have long out-patient waiting times. We noticed duplicate referrals (patients on the waiting list) being re-referred because the patient still had not been seen. These re-referrals waste consultant and administrative time, pose a clinical risk by distracting clinician time, and are costly to our health service.
Methods: We prospectively collected duplicate referral data over a 3-month period (1 October 2020-31 January 2021) in order to estimate costs. We costed (1) referring consultant and administrative time; (2) stationary, postage, and storage cost; and (3) receiving consultant and administrative time processing these referrals.
Results: We noted 82/986 (8%) referrals to our service over the trial period were duplicate. The mean length of time between first and duplicate referral was 306 days. In 35/82 (42.68%), a duplicate referral had already been received (e.g. 3rd or more referral for same patient). In total, we received 132 re-referral letters for 82 patients. Duplicate referrals changed triage outcome in 7/82 (8.54%) cases.
Conclusion: National Treatment Purchase Fund data suggests that 271,560 patients are waiting > 12 months for both in- and out-patient public appointments on 1 January 2021. Assuming duplicate referrals are occurring across the Irish health system with equal frequency after 12 months of waiting (8% of total appointments), then we estimate a conservative cost of 757,392 € per quarter to the health service and an annual cost to the HSE of 3,029,568 €.
Language
en
Citation
ISSN
eISSN
1863-4362
ISBN
DOI
10.1007/s11845-021-02866-y
PMID
35001335